From the publishers of the Journal of Antiques & Collectibles
Home » New York » Shelter Island
Antique Shops in Shelter Island, NY
1 listing · Updated November 10, 2026
Shelter Island, NY has 1 antique or vintage shop listed on Antique Shop Finder. Within 20 miles you will also find shops in Greenport, Southold and Sag Harbor. Every listing has the address, phone and directions. Call ahead to check hours, and save shops to plan your route.
Plan a trip to Shelter Island Shops on your drive, who is open that day, and shows nearby. Or tap Add to trip on the shops you like.
Shops in Shelter Island, NY
Antique shops near Shelter Island, NY
Antique Shops · 4.2 mi
Peddlers Rest Antiques & Frame Shop
56340 Main Rd, Southold, NY 11971
(631) 765-3236
Antique Shops · 4.6 mi
Southold Historical Museum Gift Shop and Offices
54325 NY-25, Southold, NY 11971
(631) 765-5500
Questions
How many antique shops are in Shelter Island, NY?
There is 1 shop listed in Shelter Island, NY on Antique Shop Finder.
Are there more antique shops near Shelter Island, NY?
Yes. 8 more shops are within 20 miles, including Lydia’s Antiques & Stained Gls, The Times Vintage and Peddlers Rest Antiques & Frame Shop.
How do I add my shop?
Listing is free. Add your shop or claim your listing at https://antiquesshopfinder.com/add-your-shop/. A real person checks every shop, usually within two business days.